Sunday, March 21, 2010

Unconverted Ministry

A recent post by Al Mohler raised an important issue. It traced an article about unconverted pastors and pointed to this comment in the article as a key.

"The ambiguity about who is a believer and who is an unbeliever follows inexorably from the pluralism that has been assiduously fostered by many religious leaders for a century and more: God is many different things to different people, and since we can't know if one of these conceptions is the right one, we should honor them all. This counsel of tolerance creates a gentle fog that shrouds the question of belief in God in so much indeterminacy that if asked whether they believed in God, many people could sincerely say that they don't know what they are being asked." - Daniel C. Dennett and Linda LaScola, Center for Cognitive Studies at Tufts University (emphasis added)

Since this was written by two atheists it could be easy to dismiss their comments as unworthy of consideration. Nevertheless there is a truth involved in the article and in the comment quoted above. Some Church leaders have been guilty of teaching in accordance with the passage emphasized above, it is true. But that is certainly not the idea intended by those who argued for a disestablished Church in the early days in the USA. In fact it would not be true to assume that the early fathers of the nation believed in pluralism at all. They saw themselves as setting up (as can be seen by the Declaration of Independence) a Christian State where no one denomination was to be given State support.

The problem with such a view is that the benefit of State encouragement to correct errors in the Church and vice versa has been largely attenuated. Though still possible, it is frowned upon as interference in the free exercise of our liberties if either institution dares to speak out against abuses in the other. Now, I am not arguing for a return to an established Church. It is wise, however, to remember that though no Church was established in the USA there was an established religion - Christianity.

While that means no one Church's teaching is to be accepted as completely correct there are certain basic tenets which hold true over all the Christian Churches. So it is patently untrue to say "God is many different things to different people" as if that includes denying he even exists. Christianity as it was accepted by the fathers was clear about the doctrine of God. He is as described in the Apostle's Creed. Most Christians would also accept the Nicene Creed and the declaration of the Council of Chalcedon on the nature of Christ.

The unconverted ministry mentioned in Al Mohler's article have no right to claim ambiguity as a reason for remaining in the role they have chosen. The honorable thing to do would be to acknowledge their unbelief and leave. In this day they would still be allowed to set up their own worshiping community (possibly even made up of their former parishioners) and even to call it a Church. In fairness, however, they should stop using the name Christian to describe their beliefs. That's more than a courtesy, that's ceasing to use the name of God in vain and so is marginally safer when it comes to the Final Judgment, even though it will not change the verdict.

Friday, March 19, 2010

Sermon at Pentecost

Occasion: The Baptism of the Church in the Holy Spirit (promised by the Lord Jesus). The is the only unambiguous example of a baptism in the New Testament. But its significance is not in the method used to baptize but in the result of that baptism. By sending the Holy Spirit Jesus gave notice to the world that he had been given all authority in heaven and on earth. Though we are removed from the events in Acts 2:1-36 by over 20 centuries yet, in principle - by our sins - we are as guilty of crucifying Jesus as the Jews of the time. Peter's sermon on that day is, therefore, something we all need to hear.

The festival of Shavuot celebrates both the end of the wheat harvest (in Israel) and the giving of the Law at Mount Sinai. This was the occasion for the gathering of the Jews in Jerusalem. It was a cheerful crowd who gathered. No doubt most had forgotten the events of that last Passover (if they even knew) for the disciples had been out of the public eye.

They had been meeting with Jesus and had been given indisputable proof of his resurrection during this time. Though greatly encouraged by the events of the weeks since Passover and though they did gather together it appears they still followed a policy of not making themselves obvious. The coming of the Holy Spirit changed all that.

Peter's sermon was the first of many that were to trouble some of the Jewish nation for the next 100 years. The theme was particularly troubling. Peter, as others would also do, proclaimed Jesus was the promised Messiah. Scripture, events they had witnessed and God raising him from the dead acknowledged him as such. He finished by reminding them of the contrast between God's treatment of him and theirs.

Content: Peter answered the charge that the disciples were drunk as a "reason" why they were behaving strangely by pointing to the Scripture (Joel 2:28-32) as the real explanation.
1. Jesus is the Christ: He then reminds his hearers of the events they had heard of Jesus of Nazareth and which, no doubt many had actually witnessed. These, events; the miracles, wonders and signs were (as everyone knew) indications of God's favor. Yet, in accordance with God's predetermined plan and foreknowledge they (the Jewish people) had him nailed to a cross, putting him to death.
2. Jesus was resurrected: This was the explanation of a passage in Psalm 16:8-11 which apparently speaks of God not abandoning David's soul to Hell nor allowing God's "Holy One" to see corruption. "We know," says Peter, "that David both died and was buried and his tomb is with us to this day..." Obviously it couldn't be David but, being a prophet he looked forward to speak of his descendant Jesus of whom this was true. Peter points to himself and his fellow disciples as witnesses of the fact that God raised him from the dead.
3. Jesus is Lord: Now, having ascended into heaven, Jesus sent forth the Holy Spirit resulting in the manifestations they had heard and seen. For (remember the disciples are witnesses) David did not ascend into heaven but Jesus did, so Psalm 110:1 applies to him, not David. So, because this is so, they need to remember that it was God who made him both Lord and Christ and they had put him to death.

Monday, March 15, 2010

Common Grace and natural theology

Definitions:
Common Grace - the operation of the Holy Spirit whereby he restrains our sinfulness so that we are not as sinful as we might become.
Natural Theology - the idea that we can deduce the character of the gods from what we learn from nature.

Beginning - presuppositions
Romans 1 and 2 teach us about sin. The natural man knows the things of God from nature so that he is without excuse because knowing God he did not worship God nor was he thankful. Changing the truth of God into a lie he worshiped and served the creature rather than the creator. He shows the effect of the Law written on his heart when he accuses others of wrong doing because he does the same things.

Common Grace gives a basis to confront the sinful
If Paul is correctly interpreted here we must assume that any identification of the characteristics of God from natural theology by sinful man must be flawed. This is because the intent is to suppress the truth in unrighteousness. Yet, such is the effect of common grace that, no matter how consistent the attempt or how ingenious the argumentation, God's truth is still able to be discerned under the dross. Common Grace restrains the impiety of the sinful. Even in his attempts to create gods he retains enough truth for it to be used to show he has no escape from God's just condemnation.

Paul demonstrates the use of this fact when making his dispute on Mar's Hill. He shows that worshiping God does not require temples nor is God like a idol of wood or stone, since we are all his offspring. (The last is claimed to be a quotation from a heathen poet.)

He makes use of the same fact when he brings the Jew to the judgment seat of the Law and shows that according to the Bible no one was ever able to keep the law well enough to merit salvation - indeed the patriarchs received the promises of God before the Law even existed. Salvation comes by faith.

Natural Theology exalts reason over the Bible
Although there have been some very good arguments advanced on the basis of natural theology to describe the characteristics of God, at heart this method makes reason the final test of truth.

What is the truth which the Reformed theologian, who would use natural theology properly, is concerned to maintain? That natural reason, by the operation of the Holy Spirit, can truly interpret nature to understand God correctly. The Reformed theologian points out that this reason is impelled by the Holy Spirit to make statements which are true to reality. Even though the person concerned may never become a Christian. Pythagorus' Theorum, for example, is true even though it was written by a pagan philosopher. Since this deals with something about which the Bible is indifferent or about which it says nothing, it is felt this idea is a safe way to express a guarded acceptance of natural theology.

And the truth the proponents are also concerned to maintain? The plain statement of the Bible that "the heavens declare the glory of God and the firmament show forth his handiwork." To interpret any fact of the universe without seeing it in relation to God's glory is to distort the fact. Pythagorus may be right if we ignore the fact that it is God who set up the relationship in the first place and that this reflects a little of his glory. Otherwise there is a whole dimension which is missing and the interpretation of the universe which it presents is flawed.

It is my contention that the attempt to maintain a natural theology as described above eventually allows the auditor to decide that the Bible is not the final arbiter of everything we need to believe for faith and life. The Bible itself needs to be tested by reason before being accepted as true. This is, I believe, what has led us to the present crisis in evangelical Churches. Far from creationist science being part of the anti-intellectual backlash, it is representative of those who would remind us that reason also is affected by sin and needs to be corrected by the word of God.

Monday, March 1, 2010

Denominational Character

I remember the way my wife used to characterize the Reformed Churches of which we were members: "Whenever there's a problem," she would say, "their solution is to clear the slate and start all over again." Recent debates over what it means to subscribe to the Westminster Confession of Faith in several Presbyterian Churches in the USA have made me think of this once again. Having come from a Reformed denomination with a distinctly New Zealand flavor (we subscribe to both the WCF and the Three Forms of Unity) has given me a somewhat different perspective not only of the issue but also of the issue under debate.

Before we get too involved - and in fairness to you, dear reader, let me say that I think the following statement, by Bishop J C Ryle, expresses fairly well what my time as a minister of the Reformed Churches of New Zealand has taught me. J C Ryle was a 19th Century, Evangelical Bishop in the Church of England (the first Bishop of the new see of Liverpool). He has become one of the best known evangelical authors of that period, equally as well-known as C H Spurgeon.

This to what he had to say about what he considered to be the required characteristics of a national Church:
"To be as comprehensive as possible consistently with reverence for the rule of Scripture should be the aim of every well-constituted National Church. Reason and common sense alike point this out. It should allow large liberty of thought within certain limits. Its necessaria should be few and well defined. Its non-necessaria should be very many. It should make generous allowance for the infinite variety of men’s minds, the curious sensitiveness of scrupulous consciences, and the enormous difficulty of clothing thoughts in language which will not admit of more than one meaning. A sect can afford to be narrow and exclusive; a National Church ought to be liberal, generous, and as ‘large-hearted’ as Solomon (1 Kgs. 4:29). Above all, the heads of a National Church should never forget that it is a body of which the members, from the highest minister down to the humblest layman, are all fallen and corrupt creatures, and that their mental errors, as well as their moral delinquencies, demand very tender dealing. The great Master of all Churches was one who would not ‘break a bruised reed or quench smoking flax’ (Matt. 12: 20), and tolerated much ignorance and many mistakes in His disciples. A National Church must never be ashamed to walk in His steps. To secure the greatest happiness and
wealth of the greatest number in the State is the aim of every wise politician. To comprehend and take in, by a well-devised system of Scriptura"


One of Ryle's famous statements is that made when he took up the role of Bishop of Liverpool. He said: "I ask you to assist me by cultivating and encouraging a spirit of brotherly love, charity and forbearance among Churchmen. In a fallen world like ours, and in a free country like England, it is vain to expect all men to see all things alike and to interpret the language of the formularies precisely in the same way. Let us on no account be colourless Churchmen, destitute of any distinct opinions. But so long as any brother walks loyally within the limits of the Articles and the Prayer Book, let us respect him and treat him courteously, even when we do not altogether agree with him." In Presbyterian terms we would read "the Articles and the Prayer Book" as "The Westminster Confession and the Book of Order" (though how many of the Presbyterian denominations in the US actually still include the Book in their standards is debatable).

It was his intention to defend the evangelical interpretation of the Reformed doctrines as described in the 39 Articles of the Church of England while allowing the freedom for other interpretations of those articles. Bearing in mind the variety from those whose views were very close to Roman Catholic to those who had become enamored of the new German Higher Critical approaches. As long as they ascribed to the confessional standards he would accept that they had the right to belong to the Church. He would defend the standards but he would not be as he said: "a party man." To be so would be to become sectarian.

Now it is true that in England the Anglican Church is an established Church and so what he said was in a different context, but consider the situation where we are talking about a denomination that is supposed to represent those who adhere to a particular confessional standard. If we call ourselves evangelicals and Reformed should we not be very sensitive to the attitude of our Master and Lord? Though he differed forcefully with those teachers of his age who were of different opinions he never left the Church to found a new one. Neither did his disciples unless their message was totally rejected. While there was hope of being heard they remained - they had to be thrown out.

This is why, as an active member of the Church he took part in all the meetings where his voice could be heard always standing for the doctrines of Grace, always defending the standards of the Church and always with respect for those with whom he differed. It was his belief that God is greater than we can comprehend and that, because of that, there will always be differences in how we strive to express our understanding of him. That being the case, in a truly Christian Church, we should grant the expression of those differences as long as the necessary marks are retained. Hence the need for those marks to be few and for us to accept variety in those things which are less necessary. It would seem the Ryle would find himself very much at home in the Confessing Movement and the Alliance of Confessing Evangelicals. It seems that even John Calvin might have felt himself at home in principle - though he might have had difficulties sustaining his membership after some of the members heard his views on their denomination's teachings. The Reformers of his day were, after all, a lot less tolerant than we are today.

Perhaps there is still hope that some of the debates at present in the Churches can be carried on in a manner which will minimize the divisions, some of which may not be as beneficial to the denomination as the protagonists believe. Here's a link to a debate that typifies (in the comments) the way I think such differences can be carried on for the benefit of the Church.

Friday, February 26, 2010

Faith and Salvation Part V

5. The Ground of Faith One final lesson we must draw from the passage I mentioned above in Matthew 25. Jesus, as the judge, states his relationship to those he is judging. He says that their treatment of his brethren was the way they had treated him. Given the relationship Jesus now has with the world we live in - he is its King and Lord - I would be remiss to leave our discussion without making it quite clear that faith comes as a result of a relationship. "Abraham believed God," we are told, "and it was counted for him as righteousness." His actions all followed on the heels of his relationship to God. A relationship of trust and affection - Abraham was called the friend of God.

What a beautiful thing to be called. And what a picture of the closeness that comes to those who walk, like Abraham, by faith. We know we do not do things as we want to in serving our Lord, but the closeness of our relationship means we can come to him and ask him to show us how to do better. We may see things happening that cause us to fear yet, when we come and seek his glory we can rest assured that he has everything under his control. The Bible is full of wonderful pictures of the relationship between the believer and God. Pictures which show the attitude between them and the things each does for the other.

It is not for nothing that an old Catechism tells us that the chief end of man is to glorify God, which we do by obeying his commandments, and enjoy him forever. Both the good and the wicked will spend their time after the final judgment in the presence of God. For the wicked this will be an eternal torment that even though they make their bed in Hell, they cannot not get away from him. For the good this will be eternal joy that no matter where they turn they are in the presence of the one they love above all else and who, without regard to merit on their part, loves them in return.

The five solas hang together as parts of a rich tapestry of our understanding of the nature of God and of his actions on behalf of man. I hope I have supplied enough to help that understanding become a little clearer so we may love him, and serve him a little more faithfully.

Go back to Part IV

Faith and Salvation Part IV - Works

4. Faith changes one's life. This is because of the internal change that takes place when we believe. Before he is regenerated there is no difference between the believer and the unbeliever. Both are completely - to use a Bible phrase - "dead in their trespasses and sins." That means there is no acknowledged spiritual awareness. There is no willingness to acknowledge the true God; no thankfulness.

Then the Holy Spirit, using the preaching of the Gospel, bring spiritual life where there was none before. This opens the believer's eyes to see the danger he is in. In the midst of the shame, confusion and fear that danger engenders he shows Christ offering to take our place. So clear is the sense of danger and so genuine Christ's offer that we cannot but accept; believing he can and will do as he says. Whenever the Holy Spirit acts there is always life and faith follows. At that point the Holy Spirit takes up residence in our hearts; encouraging us to follow the new promptings we feel to serve God. So we learn to do what we can to acknowledge his glory. The change is dramatic but real.

There are two major areas of change: The first is attitude and the second is behavior. Jesus made the difference between salvation by faith alone and its arch-rival "salvation by works" absolutely clear in a picture of the Last Judgment. Remember that, before being born again, there was no difference in either attitude or behavior between the believer and the unbeliever.

a) Changes in attitude: In the picture Jesus gives the difference between those who went away to enter the joy of their master and those who went away into everlasting darkness was shown by the attitude each had to their deeds. The wicked said they had always done what they should. And the good could never remember a time when they had.

The wicked believed they had done enough to merit being accepted. Their attitude was they had never done anything wrong so were worthy. Such has always been the attitude of the wicked until brought into the presence of God. Even when expressed as: "I have always loved my fellow man, even if I have not always done as much as I might have to help him. Therefore I am much better than this hypocritical Christian who says he loves God and is (in reality) no better than me." Their response shows their trust is in their works. Though the forms of work people trust in have become more subtle as the centuries have passed, the attitude remains the same.

During the time of the Reformation there was a common error which sounded like salvation by "faith alone," but the view of faith was faulty. Faith was viewed as something we offer to God, on the basis of which he accepts us into his kingdom. God is not (on this view) able to save anyone unless that person lets him. So, when the Holy Spirit chooses to regenerate a person, that choice is on the basis of "foreseen faith." This view has a particularly pernicious result in today's Churches. The unbeliever is taught that "all you need to do is trust in Jesus and pray this prayer. Claim your salvation and you will be saved."

Apart from the mechanical nature of the idea (which has more of magic that true religion about it) it rests on a flawed view of sin. It is believed that God, working through the Holy Spirit, brings us to a neutral point and offers us salvation and we are left to make the choice which he has foreseen we will make. Unlike the situation described above where the nature of our perceptions drives us to accept and believe, this view has the danger presented so that, should we wish to do so, we can refuse Christ's sacrifice. Some it is claimed actually do.

So, in the final analysis, our salvation rests on our choice - the choice whether to put our faith in Christ. The truth is that we do need to make a choice and the consequence of the choice is real. But when God, the Holy Spirit chooses who is to be born again he does so without regard to anything they have done or will do, so that no one can glory in their own skills or wisdom. Because these people place their trust in "their faith" - they never left the Lord Jesus knocking at the door without opening it - they belong with the first group (above) who trusted in their works.

The second group in the story knew everything they had done was flawed because the sin which remained in them made their every work unworthy. They understand the glory of God, they know his standard is absolute perfection and, they agreed that, if they were to offer anything to God it had to be unflawed. They may feel on occasion they are doing better in his service but their desire to do their best means they are never satisfied they have actually done anything which pleased to him. They accept readily enough that God loves them and is gracious to forgive them when they fail. Yet, so great have been the benefits God has bestowed on them, all they want to do is spend the rest of their lives serving him.

Like the unbeliever they would agree they don't do as much as they would like and that they are no better (when measured by the standard of the Law) than any other sinner. But, where the unbeliever is satisfied with that state of affairs, they who love God keep striving to improve even though content to trust his grace. They hope to spend eternity in heaven but God has already given them more than they had a right to expect, so they are happy to leave the final judgment in his hands knowing he will be glorified even if he should send them into the outer darkness.

Great is their amazement to discover that, as the Apostles had told them, they had been judged to have done all that God had expected of them. They believed in the sufficiency of Christ's sacrifice and it had been accounted as righteousness for them.

b) Changes in behavior: Having stressed the priority of faith, is there a place, then, for works? What, if any is the the relationship of faith to works. Jesus makes the judgment plain on the basis of their works. This is significant. Plainly then works does have a place in the judgment but what place?

There is a group who would argue it has absolutely no place. They imagine that "we are saved by faith alone" means works plays no part in the test. In dealing with Matthew 25, they stress the attitude and ignore the rest. Freedom from the Law of God absolves them of every sin they might ever commit. And, so far as that statement is concerned, they are correct. It is certainly a temptation that comes to all who understand that every attempt to keep God's Law fails because it is imperfect. Faced with that reality it is tempting to not even try to keep the Law.

Then there are those who view Christ as if once you have faith in him and allow him to guide your actions, he will give the advice necessary to save your marriage, fix the problems with Government, enable you to get a job so you have enough to live on. Heeding his advice or guidance to improve your life her on earth is "living by faith" and so you will be acceptable.

These views betray a misunderstanding of the true nature of faith. The first treats faith as if it is intellectual assent. The second as if faith enables us to correct the imbalances of our lives - apart from considering what God may intend. The Apostle James dealt with a group who also misunderstood the nature of faith. He said: "... do you not know that faith without works is dead, being by itself?" "Show me your faith without works," he adds, "and I will show you my faith through my works." Faith, true faith is always focused on Christ. It is more than assent it drives us to work; work for God's glory. The works that result (and true faith always results in works) may look the same as the unbelievers' at times but they spring from a different root.

Prompted by the Holy Spirit, we respond to those around us. We see the widows and the orphans and, because we love God we respond in compassion. As we do so we slowly, through the working of the Holy Spirit, become more Christ-like. Because God assesses both action and motive, those which spring from a sincere faith in God are counted as acceptable. All others are not.

Go back to Part III
Go on to Part V

Faith and Salvation Part III - Sin

3. Faith deals with the problem of sin. The most common subject in a Christian's conversation, and the most annoying to non-Christians, is salvation (or its variations). Non-Christians have two valid responses which often appear to be ignored by modern Christians: "Saved from what?" and "Why is it necessary?" To say we are saved by ... has significance when the person you are talking to sees there is something to be saved from - like a fire or drowning. So what is it that the Christian is talking about when he says "You must be saved?"

People today consider the fact that "no one is perfect" is just the way things are. The view goes something like this: "Since evolution is a fact, there can't be a "God of creation" to whom we are all accountable. This was an old myth which modern science has demonstrated is false. It is true we do not have a perfect society but if we exercise greater/less control over the people we can bring a perfect society into being. Christianity was one way of exercising that control in the past but it is now obsolete so we need other controls."

The interesting thing about this line of reasoning is that it faces a symptom of the real problem and, while proposing an inadequate solution, imagines it will solve the main problem. I remember many discussions with thinking men in my youth on how to fix the ills of society. I also remember we had a number of (to us) well thought out solutions none of which would have worked because we always forgot to include sin as a factor in our discussions. Sin would have destroyed all our solutions because they required people to act honorably.

Sin, however, is more than just the factor which prevents people from getting along with one another. Sin cannot be removed by anything we can do, no matter how much wise counsel may mitigate its effects. Our nature is skewed towards sin so that what we desire to do is "only evil continually." As an old catechism puts it, "sin is any want of conformity to, or direct transgression of, the Law of God." It is ignoring the Law of God which leads to difficulties between humans. If that were all there was to it there might still be hope for us as humans - after all education, even education in the Law of God, can teach us how to behave properly can't it?

Let me show the real problem. Suppose we live in a house created by and for a king. We eat the food and drink the water he provides. Then, in his very presence, we deny he exists - attributing to our own cleverness the reason why we eat and drink. Then, though this is one of the grossest insults we can give him, we plan to make "improvements" to his house by destroying more than we have already.

If we would consider it a terrible thing to do to an earthly king imagine how much greater the insult to the Creator and Sustainer of the heavens and the earth who even provides us with air to breathe and a living body to do so. This is the insult, the rebellion, which requires a response from the God of heaven and earth. The response is condemnation and eternal death. This is what the Christian refers to when he says: "you have to be saved."

Tragically, no matter how hard the Christian tries to warn those around him, success is limited. The determination to deny the destruction of the world by a past flood and to believe "all things continue as they have from the beginning" has led most of our generation to ignore the most urgent message they will ever hear. For God has already appointed a time when he will judge the world for their sin.

He gave proof of this intention when he raised Jesus Christ from the dead. He has sent his messengers out to proclaim these facts. He has allowed mankind ample time to show that they are willing to turn from the path they are on - the path that leads to destruction. He has sent the Holy Spirit to strive with man and, as a result some have believed and been saved. Yet, for most of this present generation, the siren song of evolution has allowed them to ignore the need for salvation. That same false belief has made many believe there is no danger ahead so that they ignore the warnings and, like lemmings, hurry to their own destruction.

When we say we believe in salvation by faith alone we affirm that we believe in a real hell and a real judgment day. We affirm our belief that each person is completely affected by sin and that, without God's intervention, nothing they can do will be acceptable before the Lord of Hosts. Further, to say we believe we are saved by faith alone implies we accept our task to try and warn as many as possible of those bent on their own destruction, trusting the Lord will in a measure help us to save some.

Go back to Part II
Go on to Part IV